Acme Packing Company: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Voodoo Five for South Florida Bulls Fans!

Grading TT and Looking Ahead, Pt 1

The bye week. Oh, how I loathe it.

Just when things were getting exciting, a week depraved of Packers football is forced upon us. I guess I can look forward to watching the Irish embarrass their ex-coach (in a non-racial, purely football motivated manner), but even that won't bring the same level of satisfaction as a Sunday afternoon featuring the Green and Gold does. Needless to say, I despise the bye week.

But I know (well I don't actually know them) 52+ fellas who are greatly anticipating the relaxation and reprieve that this weekend's inactivity brings.

In case you haven't noticed, the Packers are pretty banged up. A football-less Sunday brings a well deserved break to several key players and gives a few guys an additional week of rest/spleen-healage before they attempt to reenter the lineup. Chuck Woodson's toe in particular deserves a spot of respite, after it's propelled the wily veteran to a collective Defensive Player of the Year-esque performance (and the stat line to back it up) throughout the first seven games.

Additionally, the bye week is an opportune time for introspection and self-analysis, as the players and coaches examine what's worked and what hasn't. And it's a chance to figure out how the hell our raggedy run defense is going to contain the most dominant backfield duo in the league,  known as the Ying Yang Twins.

Besides this immediate, week-to-week type analysis engaged in by players and coaches, a bye at week 8 is perfectly situated to give Ted Thompson a chance to reflect on his personnel moves and transaction strategies. But, more importantly, it gives back-seat GM's like myself an opportunity to evaluate the decisions that have occurred since last March based on how they've played out on the field.

Here's how TT grades out at the mid-season break:

Quarterbacks: B

Obviously, Thompson's decision to stick with Rodgers has been vindicated by #12's stellar performance week in and week out. In fact, Rodgers is playing beyond most everyone's wildest expectations. He looks like a savvy vet out there, as he calmly dissects opposing defenses. If we had a semblance of a rushing attack, we could very well be 6-1 right now.

However, Thompson's manging of "The Favre Situation" should not go without reproach. The circumstances definitely didn't provide the Packers with a winning option, but TT allowed it to degenerate from bad to worse, possibly leading to a severance of all ties with the greatest player in our franchise's history and creating deep cleavages throughout Packer Nation (seriously, look at some of these comments). Give him credit though, as he stuck to his guns and managed to salvage a decent draft pick out of it.

And what is with his decision not to bring in a competent back-up? I love Rodgers and all, and I think he's tough as nails, but if he goes down, I really would not be content with entrusting our season to Flynn/Brohm, especially with little to no help from the ground game. Honestly, even someone like Harrington, Simms, or Leftwhich would make me sleep a little better at night.

Runningbacks: C+

Ryan Grant's significant drop-off this year makes TT's decision to give him a significant pay raise look like a poor move. The situation is similar to the Javon Walker hold-out a few years ago: a young player demands more money after a breakout year and refuses to come to camp until then. Except the Pack stuck to their guns back then, and Walker ended up coming to camp anyway. Packers management looked like they made the right decision, as Walker subsequently shredded his knee and turned into a prissy prima donna. This time around, however, TT prematurely rewarded Grant for his half-season of magnificence, only to have the running back noticeably decline once he got his pay day. TT would have been better off holding fast.

Additionally, his decision to cut Vernard Morency was a head-scratcher at the time and looks like a mistake at this point in the season. Morency was the best running back on the team in August, showing incredible burst and running ability in the preseason, and was a capable receiver and blocker in the passing game. With Grant's slow start, a player like Morency could've stepped in and provided a steady rushing attack. I like Kregg Lumpkin a lot, but perhaps he would've been better suited for the practice squad.

The DeShawn Wynn ploy was a brilliant move by TT. He decided to cut the HB before pre-season began in order to make teams think the second year back really did stink. This allowed Thompson to stick him on the practice squad with little interest from around the league. With Lumpkin out, Wynn has stepped in as a decent contributor.

I love Thompson's commitment to keeping two fullbacks on the roster. Korey Hall and John Kuhn have consistently shown that they are integral parts of our offense.

Receivers: A

The Packers didn't need to make a whole lot of changes to the best WR corp from 2007. But, nonetheless, Ted Thompson was committed to improving this unit. I was a bit puzzled when we took WR Jordy Nelson with our highest pick back in April, but TT's call has proven to be the right one. Nelson has stepped into his role with ease, and although he isn't a stud yet, he's been a consistent producer. His stat line isn't exactly impressive, but his ability to do the little things, like execute crisp routes and run block efficiently, has made him a solid contributor in his first season, a feat hard to come by for a rookie wide receiver. With James Jones out, Nelson is making a push for the 3rd spot on the depth chart.

TT also brought in several other rookie WR's in an attempt to discover a gem. Although most of them didn't show much, and were either cut or put on the practice squad, this is the type of approach necessary to keep a competitive group of receivers in this day and age.

Thompson's decision to cut Koren Robinson was an unfortunate, but necessary step. I, like many other Packer fans, had been pulling for Robinson, who had made great strides in turning his life around. I'm glad we helped to resurrect his career and that he's been given a second chance, and of all places in Seattle.

Jermichael Finley, although he hasn't done much, really can't be factored into our assessment, as he was drafted based purely on potential and is a developmental prospect. Tory Humphrey has managed to stay injury free and has been a decent contributor for the Pack, making TT's decision to keep him on board the right one. But despite his best efforts, he was unable to keep TE Joey Haynos a secret, and the 6'7" rookie was snagged off our practice squad by the Dolphins.

Well, that's it for now. I'll do o-line, defense, special teams, and a preview of this upcoming off-season tomorrow.

Here's a poll for you in the meantime.

 

Poll
What was Thompson's biggest mistake of the 2008 off-season?
His horrible handling of the "The Favre Situation"
22 votes
His inability to bring in a veteran back-up QB
24 votes
Prematurely rewarding Ryan Grant
17 votes
Cutting Vernard Morency
3 votes
Taking Jordy Nelson in the early 2nd
3 votes

69 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Morency

looked really really good this preseason. i was shocked when we cut him. we couldve definitely used him wehn grant was struggling early on.

oh well.

~O'Brien~

by packerbacker on Oct 22, 2008 8:59 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Grade of Grades

Ditto on the QB situation, although I prefer letting Flynn and Brohm develop this season instead of seeing some veteran who had washed out of one (or more) franchises taking up room on the roster.

The running back situation is starting to look a lot like 10 years ago, when the Packers gave big free agent money to another big back who wore number 25 and he turned out to be a one year wonder. Then the running back position was a black hole until the Packers turned it over to a back who played college ball at Nebraska. The good news is that with Grant, TT didn’t give him much guaranteed money. So if he wants to cut his losses with Grant, he can be released in the offseason and the position can be handed over to another young running back who played his college ball at Nebraska. I’m not ready to give up on Grant, he deserves at least a full season to prove 2007 was no fluke, but it’s something to watch the rest of the season. Cutting Morency was the right move. No one else has given him a chance either.

If all TT did was draft Greg Jennings, he probably deserves an A. But he also made sure to keep Donald Driver (although he’s starting to show his age), he found James Jones (season currently is a loss due to injury) and Jordy Nelson is starting to develop into arguably the 2nd best receiver. Ruvell Martin and Donald Lee are having worse seasons, but if everything was working out, then their record would probably be better than 4-3.

by Brandon on Oct 22, 2008 11:52 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

hmmm....

I agree, I want Flynn and Brohm to develop, but not at the expense of our team’s success. If Rodgers goes down, I don’t think either of them will be able to get us to the play-offs. I forgot to mention it in my post, but I think if Rodgers goes down, the Packers will turn to a certain free-agent who knows the system and could step in and be efficient. They did it last year when they lost Rodgers for the year. So, in this sense, TT’s strategy works. Allow Flynn and Brohm maximum exposure but if Aaron goes down, bring in a knowledgeable vet who doesn’t need any on the job training. Of course, this is all conditional to where we are in the season, how are play-off outlook is shaping up, and most importantly, how confident we are with our two rookies.

Wow, nice historical parallel. I hope Grant remains more productive than Dorsey, though.
I disagree with regards to Morency though. He was playing lights out in the pre-season, and he looked like the best back on the team. Ideally, I would’ve had us keep Grant, Jackson and Morency, and take a chance on sending Lumpkin to the practice squad. With Grant struggling early on, hampered by his hamstring and rustiness, it would’ve been nice to turn to an explosive guy like Vernard. Jackson is developing into a fine third down back, but besides that performance against a hapless Detroit team last year, I haven’t seen much consistency out of him. With Morency around in the first few weeks, I believe we would’ve had a more formidable running attack.

My assessment is just from the 08 off-season to now, so I didn’t factor in TT’s performance in past drafts. Jordy Nelson has proven to be a good pick, and he’s stepped in for the oft-injured Jones very nicely. TE play hasn’t been spectacular, but that really isn’t a result of any personnel move TT made in the offseason. Lee has just been under-performing. TT’s biggest challenge within this position will probably be locking Greg Jennings up for the long term, a goal I’d let to see met this bye-week. The more Jennings plays, the more his price will go up, so the sooner the better.

"stay (green and) gold"

by Green and Bold on Oct 23, 2008 2:48 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Jordy Nelson reminds me of a white Hines Ward.

I think he can be that type of player, he is a plus blocker, runs great routes, catches everything, and is a team first guy. Rodgers is lucky to have all those young weapons.

Go to Wide World of Roto for all your fantasy news!

by JasonM on Oct 23, 2008 10:58 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Grant's been below par

but Rodgers has exceeded expectations. How Karmic…

Grant should have had his raise strictly performance-related to keep him hungry I guess. I agree about the QB back-up situation too. Never mind the playoffs, I think it’s unfair to throw a rookie of the quality of our pair behind the steering-wheel of an offense otherwise quite well stocked. A year watching the system is only fair, surely?

by rudi on Oct 23, 2008 8:30 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Acme Packing Company, the SBNation blog for fans of the Green Bay Packers.
Start posting about the Packers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Dsc00341_small
Collins and Pickett signed to long term contracts!

Recent FanPosts

Thumbnail
Glanville finally confirms he had Favre trade
Me_as_a_simpson_small
Represent Your Team in MHR's Live Mock!
10424_528302137858_173702948_31567344_967269_n_small
Possible Tickets to Packers at Patriots 2010
Ronniebrownjuke_small
Franchise Players
34_small
Eagles release G Shawn Andrews, Bears release CB Nate Vasher
03112008811_small
You Are At the Podium... Who Do You Announce the Packers Pick Is?
Friarbob2b_small
Mock Draft Help Request
Small
Ruvell Martin signs with Seattle
10424_528302137858_173702948_31567344_967269_n_small
Brady Quinn Traded to Denver Broncos
Percy_small
Selling Packers Jerseys

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Music City Miracles
Alge Crumpler Agrees to Terms with the New England Patriots
Pats Pulpit
TE Alge Crumpler has Agreed to Terms with the New England Patriots
Pride Of Detroit
Lions Will Meet with Pacman Jones, Attend His Workout

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo link

A Deeper Look At The 2009 Cowboys Running Game

Photo

Redskins Hosting Private Workout For Oklahoma QB Sam Bradford

Photo

Conflicting Reports On The Future Of 49ers GM Scot McCloughan

More from SBNation.com >


Manager

Acmepackingco_small Brandon

Author

Rubberducky_small Mitchell_M

Me_working_foh-icon_small RobertArthur

Ice_square_small texwestern