Week 16 Postgame Musings
Well then.
I really don't have much to say, as evidenced by my near-24-hour delay in posting this item. After all, my esteemed colleagues in the game thread covered it, and Brandon certainly covered the most important bits.
How many losses by 4 points or less is it now? Eight? Eight of Green Bay's ten (and pleasepleaseohPLEASELORDPLEASE keep it at ten) losses? How many times has the special teams given up crucial field position, or has the offense failed to convert a drive into a crucial score, or has the run defense yielded after 3 solid quarters of work?
So, yeah. There isn't a whole lot to say that we haven't talked about before. I do, however, have one thing I would like to say to anyone and everyone who considers themselves a Packer fan.
Stop.
Seriously, just stop. You're embarassing yourself.
You hear it on the radio (::cough::WSSP::cough::), you see it on the news, and sometimes you read it on the internet. Thankfully, this site has avoided becoming overridden with it, but it's starting to creep in, and I am nipping it in the bud. But what is this ominous 'it' to which I keep referring to?
Panic.
Don't get me wrong, I feel it building up too. It's perfectly normal. I mean, this team did go 13-3 last year with only one major departure in the offseason (and by "offseason", I really mean "right-before-training-camp-because-he-can't-make-a-freaking-decision"). The talent on this Packers' squad is better than the 10-loss team we know and love, isn't it? But if they're losing, then there must be something wrong. Yes, there must be something wrong!
But who's to blame? The coaches? Oh, yeah! It's all the coaches' fault! After all, they make the decisions. The front office? Definitely! They put this team together, including making decisions on the people who make the decisions, so it's their fault! The running back who held out of training camp? Pfft, more like a walking-with-a-limp back. The quarterback who replaced a future Hall-of-Famer? He's not fit to carry his predecessor's athletic supporter, much less take his spot! The run defense that literally defends nothing? They're easier to bypass than the French! The French, for godssakes!
Bench him! Cut him! Fire him! Throw him out of town! Exile his family and burn his children's schools! Tar and feather him! Deport him to Morocco! Replace him! I don't care who with! Just put someone else there! Bring back Brett! Bring back Dorsey! Bring back Freeman! Bring back Santana! Bring back Gilbert! Bring back Ahmad Car...I mean, LeRoy!
For anyone feeling these sorts of things, I refer you to exhibit A:
If it helps, take a couple of deep breaths. Lie down, drink a glass of water, think about kittens. Aww, cute cuddly kittens. Look at that one! It's playing with a ball of yarn! So cute!
There. Feel better? I know I do. Those darn kittens get me every time. Time to discuss the matter at hand.
Chill out, guys. Seriously. Ted Thompson should not be fired. He brought in the talent and has an outstanding track record at improving through the draft. Mike McCarthy should not be fired. He took a 4-12 team to 8-8 the following year, and 13-3 the year after that. Most of the starters who avoided injury performed very well and will easily keep their jobs, and rightfully so. The ones who didn't perform well were usually dealing with injury (A.J. Hawk, who has not been himself all year) or simply didn't have many opportunities (Ryan Grant behind the underwhelming offensive line) to shine.
Should these people be held accountable? Absolutely. Ted Thompson will never underestimate defensive line depth again after this season, and neither will Mike McCarthy call such conservative plays at crucial points in close games. Nobody deserves a free pass when you had a year like we had this year.
But (there's always a but) you can't immediately call for their heads so soon. All this "hot seat" talk is poppycock, and we all know it. C'mon, seriously, how many lucky breaks did Green Bay get this year? And then this year, well, karma has a funny way of coming back to you. Bad spots, bad calls, bad breaks, bad bounces, bad games, and even bad seasons happen. They just happen. No getting around it, past it, or through it. This season was a "perfect storm" of bad breaks. Favre leaves, Williams gets traded, Grant holds out, Jenkins gets injured, Harris almost gets killed, on and on and on. We've covered all that stuff in depth this year.
But why am I so positive on the eve of the end of such a disastrous season? Because if there's one thing I respect in the world of football, it's consistency. I don't mean just on-the-field, either. In order for a franchise to be successful, more often than not you need a high level of consistency across the board within the organization. You can't expect a team to win if you keep replacing the coaching staff or the front office managers. Look at Tennessee. Jeff Fisher has been there forever, as has most of the front office staff. They have a system they use, and they gathered the right personnel for it, and now they're a Super Bowl contender. Yeah, they had some bad years, but they've really gotten it together because they stuck with something longer than others would have.
I don't know, maybe I'm desperate for this season to be over with so we can get positive and look forward to 2009. But I promise you this, do not expect me to change course after next week, even in the unthinkable event of a loss.
0 recs |
9 comments
|
Comments
Thank you
for summing much of my thoughts on this year. Last year we caught every break there was (wining the opening game against Philly on a special teams blunder, the Redskins game on a defensive TD, the Broncos game never should have made it to OT but we still found a way to win with a big thanks to #4,) and overachieved. This year we have caught almost zero breaks and have underachieved. My gut feeling is that the “true” Packers is somewhere between last year and this year. I think we have the talent to be a 10-6 type of team. I don’t think we lost an awful lot at QB and did actually gain some (fewer picks, some scrambling for yards if no one is open). I think the defensive drop-off is what hurt us the most.
Frye is honestly gotta be one of the top 10 3rd Stringers in all of the NFL right now--colbyb
by verno329 on Dec 24, 2008 12:07 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
I am very optimistic about next year
Glad you are too! We’ve got a great young quarterback and an offense stacked with talent that just really needs some help on the line. We’ve got a young defense with a few holes (right in the line!) that can be filled. We’ll be fine.
Great point about consistency. I was thinking Monday night while watching the game that I feel very good about keeping Thompson and McCarthy around for a long time to see what they can build here.
Happy Holidays.
by Pack Man on Dec 24, 2008 2:34 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
your season of "bad breaks"
other than tossing Favre, sounds like every season of every team.
by ol Pete on Dec 26, 2008 12:35 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
How?
I’d love to hear more on the subject, if you’re willing.
"I'm so clean, cats think I sip Ajax."
by Mitchell_M on Dec 26, 2008 6:37 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
You can add up good breaks as well. Every season has plenty of both of them. Did they really have all that many injuries? Last year wasn’t great either and is either year different from most teams, most years?
by ol Pete on Dec 27, 2008 10:47 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
what "good breaks" has the team had this season?
aside from Charles Woodson saving the day a few times, almost every single lucky break went against us this season. Yes, that happens to all teams, but considering this squad’s talent, it’s a massive irregularity. How else can you explain a positive scoring ratio AND turnover ratio on a team that will finish with at least 10 losses?
And how many significant injuries have we had? Let’s see:
Josh Sitton’s knee in preseason, when he was slated to start at RG
Ryan Grant’s hamstring in preseason, after his holdout
James Jones’ nagging knee injury lasting for seemingly the entire season
Charles Woodson’s toe for most of the season
Al Harris’ spleen in Week 3 against Dallas
A.J. Hawk’s groin injury that had a huge impact on his play
Cullen Jenkins’ shoulder injury putting him on I.R.
Aaron Rodgers’ shoulder injury that he played through when rehab may have healed it faster
Nick Barnett’s ACL, putting him on I.R.
Atari Bigby (shoulder, knee, ankle) all year long, keeping him out of games and eventually on I.R.
Nick Collins’ various ailments that, despite his performance, limited him somewhat
Aaron Rouse’s injury that forced Woodson to play safety
Justin Harrell not getting off the PUP list until week 6, then being nicked up every single week
Mark Tauscher’s knee injury, putting him on I.R.
Chad Clifton’s knee ailments that actually forced the team to bench him against Atlanta
Scott Wells’ “trunk” injury that kept him out for the beginning of the season
Brandon Chillar’s groin that ruined any chance of containing opposing TE’s for a few weeks
Those are all major contributors, and the majority of them are starters. You really think that injuries didn’t play a significant role this year? I don’t make this point to make an excuse, but you have to take the time lost and sub-standard performance thereof into account.
"I'm so clean, cats think I sip Ajax."
by Mitchell_M on Dec 27, 2008 12:36 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
to me the biggest thing about the injuries to our O-line was that it didn’t allow for any continuity. It seemed like every week there was at least one guy who had changed positions on the line, for various reasons. There was never any time for these (admittedly substandard) guys to gel and see if they could improve. The guards were our toughest spots to fill but this year also proved we need to bring in at least one rookie tackle that we hope can take over sometime soon.
Frye is honestly gotta be one of the top 10 3rd Stringers in all of the NFL right now--colbyb
by verno329 on Dec 28, 2008 6:45 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Hey this was really a great article...
I have to admit I did my share of the Chicken little, sky-is-falling bit during the postgame of the bears game (I think I was just more mad at seeing us lose to the bears)…but seeing how teams that have won 11 or more games in the past have come back and done subpar the next year (kinda like San Diego and Jax this year), it seems that it’s sorta built into the parity goal of the league and also the law of averages. We played A LOT more tougher teams than we did last years (that’s the parity goal), injuries compared to last year is just a joke (that’s the law of averages).
IN all honesty, we are not as good as a 13 win team…not as bad as a 5 win team…I think we have a team right smack dab in the middle of that, about 9 wins….which is great because we are arguably the youngest team in the NFL.
And there is no way that it’s McCarthy’s fault (I mean, did he forget to coach from one year to the next?)
by PackFaninFL on Dec 28, 2008 2:42 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
And there is no way that it’s McCarthy’s fault (I mean, did he forget to coach from one year to the next?)
Don’t let Jarlsberg or SSreporter hear you say that
Frye is honestly gotta be one of the top 10 3rd Stringers in all of the NFL right now--colbyb
by verno329 on Dec 28, 2008 6:41 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs

by 


















