Acme Packing Company: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



New Blog: Five For Howling - for Coyotes fans Bar-right-arrows



Brett Favre Arrives In Green Bay

He forced the issue, got on a plane and flew up to Green Bay to report on Monday in advance of his reinstatement. Mike McCarthy was excited, oh so excited, to have his starting quarterback back that he made this statement:

(So Brett comes back with no promises of being able to compete for the job?)
There have been no promises. Once again, there has been indecision throughout Brett's path back here to Green Bay. It's important for us to sit down, communicate. There are some things that we need to go through and then once again, from that information that comes out of that conversation will be used to move forward in the decision we'll make for our football team.

They need to communicate? He doesn't realize that Favre wants to play football again, and wants to start for the Packers? That's an unbelievable statement.

According to this report on ESPN, it will be an open competition between Favre and Rodgers, and the Packers are still exploring a trade. It isn't a competition, they are using it to showcase Favre. Let all the other GMs see that he can still play, and wait for someone to make an offer before the end of training camp. Rodgers is still GM Ted Thompson's guy.

Favre seemed offended at the idea he would have to compete for the starting job during his FOX news interview. "Why, would be my question to them," Favre said. He and McCarthy are going to have one heck of a great conversation on Monday.

Gene Wojciechowski has another great article here, but I don't think "Rodgers gets his best chance." It's Rodgers job to lose, so says McCarthy:

(Is the direction of the team still to go with Aaron as the starting quarterback?)
If we played a game tomorrow, Aaron Rodgers would be the starting quarterback. I'm not going to change any direction that we have gone with this football team based on the information that I have today. That's part of our conversation tomorrow, but we have all of the confidence in the world in Aaron. I think he is a player that is on time. He has earned this opportunity, three years preparing for it, and I'm very comfortable with him as our starting quarterback.

After working with Favre for two seasons, the last one a Pro Bowl performance, McCarthy says Rodgers his is starting quarterback because Favre missed a bunch of practices in 2008. He missed the first week of training camp at the team's request, but that doesn't matter either. Does that mean any veteran that missed a bunch of practices so far should be considered a backup because the team's moved on? Should DE KGB be demoted because he's missed most, if not all, the team's practices and minicamps so far this season due to his knee injury and the Packers moved on with DE Michael Montgomery? I'm being silly to make the point that Favre is not wanted and will not be given a real opportunity to win a starting job back although he's done nothing on the field to lose it.

Poll
Will Favre Get A Fair Chance In Training Camp To Win The Starting Job?
Yes
58 votes
No
74 votes

132 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 7 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Fair Compromise

I think, now that Brett Favre is in camp, this QB competition will be very similar to what is going on with the New York Jets. The coach and the GM would strongly prefer that Aaron Rodgers outplay Brett Favre and “earn” the starting job, but it will certainly be a difficult hill to climb. Rodgers will almost certainly start at least the first preseason game and then we’ll go from there.

Favre provides a nice insurance policy if Rodgers struggles, and if Favre looks anything like he did last year then McCarthy will probably be forced to give him the starting job or risk losing credibility with the other 52 guys on the roster.

The circus is now officially in town – let’s see how it plays out. The real question, of course, is what happens if Favre “loses” the competition?

by Packschmid on Aug 4, 2008 8:15 AM CDT   0 recs

I'm not all that happy that Favre is back

Poor Rodgers has been working his tail off and never playing because we had Favre. Now, right when he was gonna be given the chance to start and get in some real playing time before he starts getting too old to play, Favre gets cabin fever and decides not to stay at home.

I can understand Favre’s POV and I don’t blame him. However, I don’t think this is fair for Aaron at all. If they make Brett the starter, I think they should trade Rodgers to a team that’ll actually use him.

"Brett Favre looks like a man in a parking lot playing with boys." - John Madden
"Pujols just unloaded." - Bob Uecker

by kirbir on Aug 4, 2008 11:22 AM CDT   0 recs

No market for Rodgers now

I can’t see trading Rodgers now as a viable option. That’s why the Favre thing is so frustrating – we could have gotten something for Rodgers before the draft, but now we have to pretty much wait until next offseason when we’re right back in the same boat.

Hope the QB coach spends some time with Brian Brohm this season

by Packschmid on Aug 4, 2008 12:44 PM CDT   0 recs

This whole situation makes my head hurt.

I think the most interesting thing is that Favre would be willing to play for a different team. He’s mostly setting himself up to fail and tarnish his legacy, but I’m sure he’s not thinking about that.

And perhaps his determination to play is now largely just because he’s PO’ed that the Packers didn’t welcome him back with open arms. I can understand why they didn’t, but I can also understand why he wouldn’t understand that.

by Frank Madden on Aug 4, 2008 3:46 PM CDT   0 recs

nice to see you over on these boards, Frank

-- "I do know that I plead the fizzif."

by Mitchell_M on Aug 4, 2008 9:43 PM CDT to parent up   0 recs

Open Competition

What a novel concept! I can’t believe this wasn’t an option earlier in this saga to save us all a headache. I think its obvious Favre isn’t going to win it because TT wants his boy in there. All I can say is that from what I saw from training camp and from what I read about family night (I taped it on the NFL Network since Im from IL), the offense kinda….sucks. TT letting his ego get in the way of the ultimate goal of winning super bowl. Getting Favre is like getting the big FA QB on the market in my eyes. I don’t like Favre got to this point, but hopefully he can put his arm where his mouth is.

"You just don't know understand how frustrating this is"- Kevin Borseth

by TkGoUWGB on Aug 4, 2008 7:01 PM CDT   0 recs

I want this to go away

And Favre with it. He’s my favorite sports player of all time but he’s really hurting my respect for him. This isn’t fair to Rodgers at all, how’s he supposed to play well with that kind of pressure? 3 Years on the bench, he gets his chance and now he has one of the best quarterbacks of all time breathing down his neck. I love Favre, but I’m ready to move on to a new age.

by Pack Man on Aug 4, 2008 9:31 PM CDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Acme Packing Company, the SBNation blog for fans of the Green Bay Packers.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Donald Driver's Father in Hospital after Police Beating

Recent FanPosts

Packers_small
Frost Released!!
Small
No Playoffs, but Packers Still in Good Hands with Rodgers
Small
Thank you Mike McCarthy
Catscratchreader_m_small
Blogger Q&A with a Panthers Blogger
Tbsportsbloglogo_small
2009 Pro Bowl - AFC vs. The Washington Redskins?
Erindavewhodat_small
Ask Canal Street Chronicles!!
Image_021_small
The All NFC North Team
Timbreakin_small
Thursday Injury Update
Windycity_small
Bears Questions Answered Here

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter