The Schofield Report: 12/12/10
This is the first ever Schofield report. I'd like to think it's a work in progress that captures the work of the team in a day's performance, but it can be lambasted, destroyed, and hated if you wish it to be so.
A 7-3 loss to the Detroit Lions drops the Packers to 8-5. A quick recap of the season...
Packers 27, Eagles 20: Packers knock Kevin Kolb out of the game and survive Michael Vick's 2nd half onslaught for their first win in Philadelphia in several decades.
Packers 34, Bills 7: Packers knock Trent Edwards out of the game, and the Bills decide to give Edwards the boot for good.
Bears 20, Packers 17: Poor play by the Packers allows the Bears to stay in the game, and the Bears win a game the Packers would love to have back.
Packers 28, Detroit 26: Packers do just enough to win, but this game tastes bad afterwards.
Redskins 16, Packers 13: Rodgers knocked out in OT, another game the Packers would love to have back.
Dolphins 23, Packers 20: Packers can't close out Dolphins in regulation and lose heartbreaker at home.
Packers 28, Vikings 24: Packers finally close out an opponent, with no small amount of help from a certain QB 4's interceptions.
Packers 9, Jets 0: The stunner of the season? Mark Sanchez serves up a disaster against the Packer defense as the Jets get shut out at home.
Packers 45, Cowboys 7: Wade Phillips gets axed after a horrible performance.
Packers 31, Vikings 3: Packers thwart unfounded revenge AND sweep the Vikings for the first time since 2007.
Last 3 Games:
Falcons 20, Packers 17: ST can't stop big kick return, and defense can't stop Falcons from marching into FG range for the game-winner after an epic drive of their own.
Packers 34, 49ers 16: A game that was too close for comfort in the 1st half turned into a 2nd half blowout.
Lions 7, Packers 3: Breakdowns below. Woe and horror within...
---
Since a loss in the 2005 season opener at Detroit, the Packers have won every single game against the Lions. Every single one. It was an impressive streak, but streaks end eventually and losing to Detroit is more upsetting than infuriating to me. Detroit has played better than their record intimates, while other teams have played far worse than their record intimates (Chicago and both New York teams come to mind). The Lions were frustrated. They badly needed a win, and they got one today. The only problem is that they beat the Packers.
Offensive Breakdowns:
Passing: Rodgers was off-target all game long. I have no idea what was going on, but he had a terrible first half and was knocked out of the game (which was a mercy). Flynn came into the game and played well, but he made a bad read in the endzone and forced a pick into double coverage, resulting in an INT by DeAndre Levy.
Grade: C-. D for Rodgers, who is capable of much, much better, and C+ for Flynn, who played very well considering how he is NOT supposed to be in the game unless the Packers lead by 3 or more touchdowns in the 4th quarter.
Rushing: No one could get the job done. Brandon Jackson was just trying to survive out there, and Starks was getting cut down on the edges all game long. Nance had little to nothing as well.
Grade: D+. Considering the failure to establish the running game, as well as the failure of the offensive line to block effectively for the backs, it's a wonder Flynn completed as many passes as he did in my opinion.
Receiving: Quarless is a rookie TE, but you can't put the ball on the turf. Ever. Jennings should be credited with an interception for his horrific gack that allowed Amari Spievey to grab the football, but he definitely caught a touchdown pass that the officials messed up on and McCarthy decided not to challenge. Swain managed some receptions, but one for a first down was dismissed because of offensive holding. Donald Driver simply couldn't get open downfield.
There was a combination of good defense by the Lions to jam the receivers and an inability to get open by Packer receivers that made Rodgers's and Flynn's days very difficult.
Grade: B-. The wide receivers and the tight ends have to get open and it didn't look like they did that well at all today. Jennings had a TD catch waived off by the officials and had a horrible gack where he knocked the ball to Amari Spievey. Amari Spievey is NOT a Packer wide receiver.
Pass Blocking: Terrible. Worse than awful. Atrocious. The QBs had less than a few seconds to react before they had to move out of the pocket, and that's never going to work with a young QB like Matt Flynn.
Grade: D-. This was a truly pitiful effort. The Lions were without Kyle Vanden Bosch and missed Cliff Avril for some of the game, and they still managed to get pressure on Aaron Rodgers and Matt Flynn.
Run Blocking: Terrible again. I'm not sure whether the OL were worse in pass-blocking or run-blocking, but an offensive line can't play as terribly as the Packers offensive line did and expect to beat anyone.
Grade: D. The failures of the line to run block made Brandon Jackson and James Starks's lives miserable today. This sort of performance will not get it done against anyone.
Grading the Offense as a Whole: C-. The offensive line didn't play well at all, making the QB play more frantic and killing the running game, and the receivers didn't help matters by dropping passes for interceptions and putting the ball on the turf. That being said, once the 2nd half started and Flynn started to play well, the offense showed some cohesion and got the ball deep into Detroit territory.
Defensive Breakdowns:
Pass rush: Good. Very good. I can't recall Drew Stanton looking comfortable in the pocket at all for the game, which is a great sign for a defense. Harrying the QB makes the QB uneasy and prone to taking sacks and throwing the ball into coverage.
Grade: A. Stanton didn't look comfortable in the pocket and was sacked twice for losses of 21 yards.
Run stopping: Not so good. Maurice Morris ran for 51 yards on 11 carries (an average of 4.6 YPC), but his longest carry of the game was 8 yards. Jahvid Best ran for 38 yards on 13 carries (an average of 2.9 YPC), which is much better. Drew Stanton, however, managed 44 yards on 4 carries (an average of 11.0 YPC, which is flat-out inexcusable).
Grade: B. The work the DL and LBs did in keeping Morris from getting long gains and slowing down Jahvid Best was good, but the outside contain on Stanton was poor.
Pass coverage: Good, but could have been much, much better. Drew Stanton completed 10 passes on 22 attempts for 117 yards with a touchdown, but he threw 2 INTs (Charlie Peprah and Tramon Williams). Stanton was wild for most of the game, but he threw the lone touchdown pass of the game to Will Heller (a screen that combined good blocking with poor defense for a perfect result, unfortunately).
Grade: B+. Heller wasn't stopping for anyone on that TD play, but with the exception of a long reception by Calvin Johnson in which the trailing Charles Woodson got burned like a torch, the Packers seemed to be wherever Stanton was throwing the ball.
Grading the Defense as a Whole: A. Holding any team to 7 points for an entire game is impressive, no matter who you play. There were breakdowns, and I imagine Capers will find a lot to improve on for next week against the Patriots.
---
End of the Day: The Packers seemed listless from the opening snap. The last time I saw a team like that was 2009 Wisconsin vs. Northwestern (which was even MORE of a heartbreaker), when NU showed up and Wisconsin didn't. The Lions simply played much, much better than the Packers today. The Packers had their share of opportunities but didn't convert in the clutch. The Lions did as well, and converted when they needed to in order to snap their long losing streak.
Next Week: 12/19/10 @ New England
OBrienSchofieldismyHero
20 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I'm just gonna kind of comment as I'm reading
Pass O – Looks pretty good… Might be a bit generous on the Rodgers D lets be honest… 7-11 for 46 yards and 1 INT thats not his fault is more of a failing grade IMO… 46 yards in a 1/2… I don’t even think they had a first down until 1/2 way through the 2nd
Rushing O – D+ is way to generous for today… should be an F no questions asked… when you’re QB who plays less then 1/2 the game leads you in rushing by 6 yards you’re running is bad… now this is a combination of run blocking which you address later and coaching… but it’s still inexscusable
Recieving – C seems decent… couple of big screw-ups (Jennings INT… Q fumble) but outside of that they were average (which when you’re running game is horrible doesn’t bode well)
I’m just going to lump your blockings together and agree… the whole O-line = F… I’d do Y’s or Z’s but the grading alphabet doesn’t go that low… the box score says 4 sacks (but i seem to remember at least 5 maybe 6) and plenty of TFL by the Lions. There’s not a lot the RBs can do when there’s multiple guys in the backfield by the time the ball is handed off. I don’t know if it’s the ZBS (I think we don’t have guys that aren’t meant for it personally) or personel (Lang at LG, Bulaga at RT) but our line is atrocious and reverting back to early 2009 form
Pass rush was pretty weak most of the game… Stanton had time to make some big third down conversions and outside of the one Clay sack, we never really “Got to Him”… Part of that might have been do to the fact the Lions ran it 41 times
Run defense… 4.6 yards per carry (3.9 if you pull Stanton’s rushes out)… the Lions continually had 2nd and 4 or 5 which is very manageable we never really seemed to stop their run. I have to give this almost a C- because 4.0 yards per carry when you know they’re going to be run heavy is below average IMO
Stanton’s accuracy was off so the pass coverage looked a lot better because he under threw guys or they dropped balls… the 2 INTs were on horrible throws and not really the result of good coverage but overall it was probably deserving of a B B-
The defense as a whole only gave up 7 points, but they seemed to get timely turnovers and did a lot of bending which works against lesser teams, but if you bend enough, you’ll eventually break like we did in the 4th. This seems to be what we’ve done a lot lately too which doesn’t bode well for us
I’m going to add coaching to your list
MM deserves about a C-… The challenge is what it is, the NFL needs to find a way to do something about this whether it be do automatic reviews in the booth or something, but it’s known that the home team gets advantages on what feeds and replays are shown (They didn’t show a single replay in the stadium until after the kickoff)… His game management wasn’t horrible he tried to establish the run in the first quarter but when it wasn’t working (less then 2 yds a carry) he went away from it which I’m ok with… The draw play on 2nd and 2 isn’t as bad as it seems (only because it didn’t work)… at that point w/ 2 or 3 timeouts left… the clock isn’t the issue, it’s about trying to get the 1st down… since we were so pass happy all 2nd half it was a nice try to catch them off-guard and get the 2 yards for the first… It didn’t work so he went to passes (otherwise he’s running it again… the same thing everyone is complaining about)… As far as the home-run attempt… Jennings was open, he had his guy beat… the throw was off… in my mind thats a proper play call w/ poor execution… Were there things that he could’ve done differently… YES… is he the worst coach ever because he didn’t NO
Overall, the defense tried to bail the O out again and couldn’t do it… it’s a tough loss but there’s still 3 games left… lets not give up yet guys
by Goldenarmadillo4 on Dec 12, 2010 8:06 PM CST reply actions
BTW
really like this idea and I was thinking of doing something really similar until I saw you had already done this
by Goldenarmadillo4 on Dec 12, 2010 8:07 PM CST reply actions
Guess I just beat you off the dribble
lol
Want me to do one next week?
Wisconsin, Big Ten Champions for the first time since 1999...
You'll notice NCAA has no letter for the incompetence within...
by OBrienSchofieldismyHero on Dec 15, 2010 9:24 PM CST up reply actions
i'd def like to see another one
and I’ll do the same long post to kick things off… If ya get busy and I don’t see one by tuesday or so… I’ll try to throw one up then
by Goldenarmadillo4 on Dec 16, 2010 2:35 AM CST up reply actions
Poor Grading
Can’t say that I agree much with your grades given to the different units…here’s what would be mine:
Offense in general: (D) Nothing was working right today, the Lions wanted the game more than the Packers did, were more inspired and came out ready for battle. Our offensive line just might be the worst in the NFL on many days, and today’s game was no exception.
Offensive Line: F
Offensive Backs: C
Offensive Receivers: D
Offensive Play Calling: D
Defense in General: © They could have (and SHOULD have) forced more mistakes by a woeful Detroit Lions Offense…that would in turn have given the Packers more scoring opportunities and better field position. As a unit, the Defense looked vanilla…just didn’t seem to have that usual fire we’ve come to expect.
Defensive Line: C
Defensive Linebackers: C
Defensive Backs: C
Special Teams: B
I can see a B for ST,
a B for defense as a whole, but everything else gets an F. Seriously. The D played well enough to win. Since when is giving up 7 pts. a sin? Of course, we often play a great game on D only to cave late.
by bigbill992001 on Dec 13, 2010 2:07 AM CST up reply actions
Coaching F
MM didn’t have them ready to play and had his usual awful play calling.
I know!
Do they know they are fighting for a playoff spot! I know the Lions arn’t the Lions of old… but still, they are not a great team! I think its time fans realize this team is not better than the Bears and not a Superbowl contender! It’s hard to be positive about the shape this team is in. Don’t mean to sound so negative, just speaking my mind :)
by Chief Oshkosh on Dec 12, 2010 10:33 PM CST up reply actions
Feel the same way. It’s troubling that we always seem to come out so flat in big games, and especially those that are against lesser opponents.
by packallday555 on Dec 16, 2010 10:20 PM CST up reply actions
If Jennings catches that ball like he usually does and Flynn doesn’t throw a bad interception you would probably feel differently about the coaching grade Wisfan.
Good play calling gone bad with player mistakes. He called that jennings bomb perfectly and jennings had about 2 or 3 steps on the guy and just dropped it.
by Nathan Schultz on Dec 12, 2010 10:13 PM CST reply actions
Jennings drop
Was absolutely inexcusable!!! That was pretty much a PERFECT pass and he didn’t just whif on it! He totally fumbled the entire play! Then didn’t even consider that the CB would come up w/ it and didn’t even try to make a tackle, just ran like he dropped an EASY catch and nothing else mattered! That play opens up the entire game for the Packers if its a TD! Great play call, and just a really POOR attempt by Jennings! Combined w/ the INT he allowed last week and I give Jennings a poor grade for the last couple weeks! I don’t care about his yds and the rest he totally failed to make a play that cost crucial INT’s…. Absolutely no excuse!!! He needs to quite reading his clippings and start playing like the player he thinks he is! Pro Bowl WR make those plays and don’t allow those kind of INT’s!!!
You've been Stroh'd™!!!
Agreed on that
I was disgusted by what he did on that play. Looked like Nick Toon after his fumble in the UNLV game, and with a similar result, a big return.
What did you think otherwise?
Wisconsin, Big Ten Champions for the first time since 1999...
You'll notice NCAA has no letter for the incompetence within...
by OBrienSchofieldismyHero on Dec 13, 2010 12:32 AM CST up reply actions
Not much to be happy about!!!
D played pretty well… Well enough to win, but far from dominant!
OL played poorly overall. The interior OL was manhandled by Suh and Corey Williams! IMO, this becomes our #1 need over OLB given this game. If we’re going to continue to beat Det we have to get better at Center and LG!! Just no 2 ways about it!
Rodgers was playing badly before going out! The throw to Jennings aside, the rest of the game is largely in his hands! He was flat, not engaged in the game and made too many poor decisions! Among them not sliding when told to… If he had stayed in the game I think we would have won tho! Either he would have got the team together and led to a W or would have been able to find a way to win a close game despite the overall lackluster play!
Just no excuse for the offenses play and that falls on Rodgers as much or more than McCarthy!!! Rodgers is THE leader of the offense on the field… And he was having a terrible day, even prior to going out, along w/ Jennings and the OL!!! RB
RB had no room to run so its hard to judge them fairly… You can’t make a judgement on their decision making if they don’t have decisions to make!
Overall the team gets an F from me… The players didn’t show up to play despite being fully aware of the importance of this game! Thats on the players more than the coachs IMO!!! Can redeem w/ a big win over NE and NYG, but this one hurts!!! Seems to me they have to win out now!
You've been Stroh'd™!!!
I think he did that because he saw the flag
The only glove he needs is a batting glove. - RWShow on Adam Dunn signing.
Then that's an even bigger issue w/ Greg
I want people that complete the play… not try to draw a flag… IF the flag is a PI then we get the ball at like the 15 or 20 yard line… if he completes the play he probably takes it to the house… If he’s out there trying to draw flags then I don’t want him… I want a guy thats going to fight through the penalty and still finish the play
by Goldenarmadillo4 on Dec 13, 2010 1:58 AM CST up reply actions
he didnt try to draw a flag, he saw a flag and thought the play was over
The only glove he needs is a batting glove. - RWShow on Adam Dunn signing.
Did a whistle blow the play dead?
NO!!! He acted like it was and that is all on Jennings!!! IMO, he owes the fans and the team an apology… That ball was spot on his numbers and he just butchered it!!! Then after the flat out drop, didn’t play to the whistle! 100% on Jennings!!! He and the OL didn’t show up at all!!! Rodgers was a little lifeless too, but I think he was trying to get guys going by running the ball a little to lite a fire under them.
You've been Stroh'd™!!!
I wasn't aware a flag meant the play was over
I thought that’s what the whistle was for… Look, I have to disagree w/ you on this… Greg Jennings needs to play from snap to whistle… Yesterday he didn’t… he thought he got the PI and stopped trying and that is unacceptable at this level of play
by Goldenarmadillo4 on Dec 13, 2010 4:40 PM CST up reply actions

by 





















