Potential First-Round OT Analysis
Now that the Super Bowl is over, we can turn 100% of our attention to the off-season and to the Packers' efforts to improve the team. As we have documented (and complained, and lamented, and...you see where I'm going here), the Packers need help on the offensive line, especially at tackle. With Chad Clifton and Mark Tauscher becoming unrestricted free agents this off-season, I feel that it's likely that one of them will be departing. Even if they both return for 2010, we need better depth and talent at the tackle position.
In light of this, I'm going to give a quick snapshot of four offensive tackles projected to be drafted in the mid- to late-first round:
Bryan Bulaga-Iowa, Trent Williams-Oklahoma, Bruce Campbell-Maryland, and Charles Brown-USC.
Bryan Bulaga - Iowa, 6'6", 310 lbs
The Rivalry, Esq. gives their draft profile of Bulaga here. I must admit, anything that is compared favorably to former Badger Joe Thomas automatically piques my interest. The question about Bulaga is whether or not he falls to the Packers at 23. Frankly, if he's around after 18 or 20, I wouldn't mind seeing Ted Thompson try to jump up a few spots and grab him. A two-year starter, Bulaga is a mauler, and though his pass-blocking technique needs some work, his mean streak is something that you need when blocking ends like Jared Allen. He played LT at Iowa, but most are projecting him as a RT in the NFL. I think he has the ability and size to play on the left side, and I would be excited if he is available for the Packers at 23.
Bruce Campbell - Maryland, 6'7", 310 lbs
Campbell didn't start at left tackle in college until midway through the 2008 season, but he's one of the highest-rated tackles in the draft. Mocking the Draft has a profile here. Draft projections for Campbell are all over the place...he's been ranked as high as 8 to the Raiders and as low as 26th in the past month. To summarize his draft reports, Campbell has had some issues with concentration and a tendency to lose focus on occasion; however, he's still young (a true junior in 2009), and that should improve in that area. He has very good mobility and size, and his upper body strength is a key. But for me, the important thing about him is that I'd love to have a guy with a chainsaw for a right hand manning the left tackle spot.

via tvtropes.org
Trent Williams - Oklahoma, 6'5", 310 lbs
Much like Campbell, Williams' projected draft slot is all over the board. He's looked at anywhere from 13th overall to the middle of the second round. Williams switched sides from right to left tackle before the 2009 season, and played well this year. He is a good athlete who has solid footwork in the passing game. However, he lacks the nasty side that Bulaga and even T.J. Lang show, and has struggled in run-blocking.
Charles Brown - USC, 6'6", 285 lbs
The thing that jumps out from that line is that Brown will need to put on some weight to be an effective NFL tackle. Brown has a similar amount of time starting in college, but as a redshirt senior, he's two years older than the other two players. Brown's footwork and mobility are both excellent, but my concern is with his strength and technique. Also, Brown played in a zone-blocking scheme at USC, which may or may not help him adjust to the Packers' pseudo-zone system. The biggest key for me is whether or not he can put on some weight before the Combine and avoid a drop-off in his footwork and quickness. (UPDATE: Mocking the Draft now lists Brown at 298 lbs)
Other than these three, there are also premier tackles Russell Okung of Oklahoma State and Anthony Davis of Rutgers, who are both projected in the top 15 picks. Were one of them to slip, I'd expect Ted Thompson to snag them quickly, but with the demand for tackles in the NFL, they'll likely be long gone by the 23rd pick.
For now, I would rank these four in the order I have listed them, but I wouldn't be horribly disappointed if we took Campbell if both he and Bulaga were available. However, if Bulaga and Campbell are both gone at 23, I would expect Thompson to either address the pass rush with an OLB like Brandon Graham of Michigan or Texas' Sergio Kindle or draft a defensive back.
1 recs |
11 comments
|
Comments
Nice analysis. If Buluga, Campbell, or Williams are still there TT should take one of them no questions asked. I also would like to see TT take either Carimi (Wisconsin) or Fox (Miami) because I think both could translate into good RTs.
Carimi was only a junior this year.
He’ll be back in Madison for his senior year in 2010. I agree that he’d be a great guy to take a flier on in the late rounds in 2011. Besides, I seem to remember Ron Wolf using a 7th round pick on a tackle from Wisconsin in 2000…
"Career highlights? I had two. I got an intentional walk from Sandy Koufax and I got out of a rundown against the Mets." - Bob Uecker
Oh really? I had remembered seeing him on a prospects list a while back so I just assumed he was going to the draft. Thanks for letting me know. Using a later round pick on a guy like Carimi could be a great pick.
by packallday555 on Feb 9, 2010 10:04 AM CST up reply actions
Good job writing this
What I saw of Bulaga leads me to believe he’ll be a RT in the NFL. He is nasty in run plays, drilling his man all the way to the first down marker. But he has a lot of work to do if he wants to be a blind-side protector in the pros; he gets beat off the snap too many times.
Hopefully we address the issue sooner rather than later.
The Dude abides
Drafting Trent Williams
unfortunately, I see it as a disaster waiting to happen.
Why is he rated so highly after failing to distinguish himself? Is this the Eric Berry effect, which is to have a great season the year BEFORE you leave college and you will win a major award after an average year?
Bulaga would be a better selection should he be available. But there’s little to no depth this year in the draft…
by OBrienSchofieldismyHero on Feb 9, 2010 9:39 PM CST reply actions
Why do you see him as a disaster waiting to happen? From all the mock drafts I’ve seen on him it appears that most scouts feel he is probably the 2nd best LT behind Okung. It scares me a bit that Buluga is now being projected as a RT. The more I look at it, the chances of there being one of the top LT prospects for us at 23 are pretty slim. If they all indeed are off the board then who do we take? Probably an OLB but even that depends on what we do with Kampman. Maybe we’d take Josh Wilson as he has impressed, and it’s rumored that TT likes him. Then there is always the possiblity of Mays. Haha gosh, I just wish it was April already!
by packallday555 on Feb 9, 2010 10:08 PM CST up reply actions
I haven't seen him higher than 3rd.
Anthony Davis has been ranked above him on most boards I’ve seen, but I suppose he’s looked at as either a LT or RT. I’d still love to see Bulaga or Campbell fall to us.
I think OB above you there is concerned that Williams didn’t really stand out this year, and I would agree that I have some concern about that as well.
"Career highlights? I had two. I got an intentional walk from Sandy Koufax and I got out of a rundown against the Mets." - Bob Uecker
The scouts are wrong if they have Trent Williams in the first round, period
He didn’t distinguish himself his last year at OU at all, in a league where the best rushers are on all of three teams, Oklahoma, Texas, and Nebraska. He was a nonfactor against both the Cornhuskers and the Longhorns (ugh). Against the weak competition of the rest of the Big Twelve, he pulled a very nice vanishing act. What did he do again?
We do need a new T, but the question is where. RT or LT? Ciron Black or Brian Bulaga would be a good pick, but I see Trent Williams as a repeat of last year’s tackles through the first eight weeks. I’d rather not see Rodgers get killed out there because his tackles can’t protect him.
by OBrienSchofieldismyHero on Feb 11, 2010 8:42 AM CST up reply actions
OT
Bulaga is going to be a Top 15 pick, IMO… He is the best pass blocking LT not named Okung. If Bulaga is available you gotta take him, he’s a true LT.
Campbell is a walking, talking injury. Worse history than Harrell, so I wouldn’t touch him till the 2nd. Williams was an outstanding RT as a Jr. who stuggled as a Sr at LT. If you draft him as a RT, he’s a 1st rd prospect EASY, as a LT he’s a late 1st…
Brown is not stout enough for the NFL! He is simply too small and most scouts think he is maxed out at a playing wt of 290 or so. Just won’t cut it in the NFL. 2nd rd based on talent, but lower if he can’t gain significant wt.
After Okung, the best of them is Bulaga, and the Packers would thank thier lucky stars if they get him at #23. IMO, he would be exactly like Clifton has for the past decade.

by 



















