Hey everyone, thank you all for voting in the Ryan Grant Poll last week and thank you for your insightful comments. Based on the success of the Grant poll, I have decided to throw another name out there and I plan on doing one of these a week. As the season moves along the names in these polls will get more and more debatable.

This week lets discuss Charlie Peprah. He filled in well last year late in the season when called upon and this year he has been called upon to start in the absence of Nick Collins. Now we can't make a 100% guarantee that Collins has played his last NFL game, but I think we can pretty much assume he has. Honestly, it would be stupid for him to consider playing again. Now back to Peprah. Charlie Peprah has made some nice plays this season but he has also been a liability in deep coverage most of the time. He improved last night against the Vikings, but still that doesn't give me a lot of faith in him long term, even for the rest of this season. However, Peprah does have value as a backup.

So, should the Packers bring back Charlie Peprah in 2012?